Visit to the crash site of 42-94841 near Holmfirth with the family of Corporal Clarence Watson

‹ Return to

Visit to the site of a B-24H near Holmfirth with the family of Corporal Clarence Watson

This post is published on the anniversary of the crash. Please see below for photos, links and acknowledgements.

In 2011, I was contacted by Mrs Vicky Weatherby who lives in California. She is the niece of Corporal Clarence Watson who was killed in the crash of B-24H ‘Sack Time’ on the moors south of Holmfirth. Clarence’s body had never been found so the crash site really is a war grave.

Vicky again was in contact in 2024, asking if there was to be any memorial service on the 80th anniversary. I asked around but no-one came back to me with anything. However, unknown to Vicky and I, an organisation called Geoscope were on site at the time, making a preliminary survey and a small dig at the site while obtaining permission for a full dig.

In January 2026, Vicky and I were again in contact, Vicky hoping to travel from California with her family to visit the site (and then onto Bastogne where her father had fought with the US Airborne Division during WWII). I offered to escort Vicky and her family up to the crash site when they arrived.

Vicky said she had received an email from the US Army which said ‘Geoscope were going back to the crash site’ but that didn’t mean anything to Vicky or to me, and initial Google searches came up with nothing. I was a bit concerned however, and so the week before Vicky arrived, I made a visit to the site, and saw that an extensive survey and dig were underway. The email from Army Casualty made sense now.

There was nobody on site at the time and it later transpired this was a rare day off for the archaeology team! I took some photos and advised Vicky that the crash site did not look how it looked in photos she will have seen, with equipment and shelters on site, tarpaulins covering parts and other parts roped off.

More specific Googling came up with the name Geoscope Services, and I emailed the Managing Director, Tim Fletcher ahead of the Americans’ visit. As it happened, Tim had just emailed me a day or so before, but his email had landed in a spam folder which was unfortunate. But by an astonishing coincidence, Tim and his crew were at the site looking for the remains of Clarence Watson at exactly the same time as Clarence’s relatives were visiting for the first time.

Tim very kindly offered to meet with Vicky and her family – daughter-in-law Lily and Vicky’s son Dustin – at their base at a farm in the hamlet of Lane, which is just below the moors upon which the USAAF bomber crashed in 1944. As well as meeting the team, we also met Emily and Emma from Moors for the Future (see below)

Tim and the crew made us very welcome, explained the methodology of their searches, what had been found already (in respect of aircraft debris) and explained how the aircraft had crashed on the moor. Then we all travelled up to the site together.

Below; Tim Fletcher of Geoscope describing to Vicky, Dustin and Lily the flight path of 42-94841. It approached from the left, the pilot unable to see the moors ahead of him in the low cloud.

7

I took this photo the week before Vicky and her family visited. The Liberator flew over Yateholme Reservoir and struck the moor.
7

Dustin, Vicky and Lily.
7

Tim returning to the crash site. It was a moving experience, and Tim and his crew and Emma and Emily thoughtfully gave the family some space and time alone upon arrival at the site.

7

Some of the Geoscope team at the site.

7

7

Group shot. The flags were just for the occasion and were removed afterwards.

7

Geoscope team back at work

7

7

Some of the finds from the dig which were taken back to the base at Lane for sorting.

7

When I visited the week before, and no-one was on site, I looked at some of the debris which had been dug up (note, this is not at the site now, it has been removed as part of the excavation and search). Tim later told me that there was debris from various aircraft in one pit. Some from a Sabre jet fighter, other parts from a P-51 Mustang. Tim pointed out that a bit of webbing from a seat had drawing pins in it. The likely theory is that someone had at some point removed artefacts from various air crash sites in the Peak District and – for reasons unknown – had buried the remains here.
7

7

7

A view of the crash site during the time the survey and dig were underway
7

Below; this is the impact point of Liberator 42-94841. Tim explained how the pilot saw the moor at the last instant, and pulled back on the stick, trying to clear the moor which had suddenly appeared in front of him. The tail struck the moor first as it tried to climb. This scar on the moor is exactly the same size as the tailplane of a B-24 bomber. Its vertical stabilisers cut into the moor, the trailing cut to the left still visible today. Geoscope confirmed this through their survey and excavation.
7

Poppy cross left by Clarence’s family
7

Vicky also brought a new memorial for Clarence

7

Corporal Clarence Watson, photo courtesy of Vicky Weatherby and used with her kind permission
7

Photo of Vicky taken as we returned to the car park and she took a last look towards the crash site where her Uncle Clarence was killed and whose remains are still on the moor.

7

I am very grateful to Tim Fletcher and his team at Geoscope Services for making us so welcome, and for their courtesy and professionalism.

Thanks also to Emma Shaw and Emily Jones of Moors for the Future. Geoscope and Moors for the Future have worked together to ensure the moor is restored following the dig. I will revisit next year and take some more photos and add them here.

And a huge thank you to Vicky, Lily and Dustin for trusting me to take them to the site, though in the event, a whole party of us went up at the same time.

Page on this website about the crash of B-24H 42-94841

BBC news item about the search, published today, 09 October 2026 which is the anniversary of the crash. The story will feature in an episode of BBC’s Countryfile to be broadcast 11 October 2026.

Look North news item, video courtesy of Tim Fletcher

2 comments on “Visit to the crash site of 42-94841 near Holmfirth with the family of Corporal Clarence Watson”
  1. Thanks, both moving and interesting. My English mother met my American father in London during WW II. He was a liaison officer working out of the Embassy. She was a clerk working at the Air Ministry. I heard them discussing the war in Europe all through my childhood, and have persued a strong interest ever since.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*